11 Comments

The Herbies

ESPN talking head Kirk Herbstreit has released his 2007 Herbies and there’s always some interesting stuff on this list, which makes its appearance for 7th year, and very few things that I think anyone can quibble with.

When you do what Herbstreit does, which is traveling from campus to campus for months during college football season, it allows him to gain a perspective that few others have. Every college town in America thinks they have the best greasy spoon, on-campus dive so to argue with Herbstreit on what college town has the best food is really an exercise in futility. It’s a matter of taste but it’s also a matter of experience, which Herbstreit has in spades. Ditto for best band, best Gameday locations, best students sections and prettiest coeds. When you travel around the country for two or three months, you get a pretty good feel for the best of the best in college football and perhaps more importantly, the culture of college football, which is what a show like Gameday is really all about. It’s the ultimate tailgate.

I take a little bit of offense to some of his picks as far as players and coaches are concerned. First there is the best running back, new wave, category where Herbstreit has Ohio State sophomore Beanie Wells listed number 1 in front of Oklahoma’s DeMarco Murray and USC freshman Joe McKnight, who has drawn comparisons across the board to Reggie Bush. Now I don’t often accuse Herbstreit, who is an Ohio State alum and co-hosts a sports talk radio show in Columbus on 1460 AM when not on assignment for the Worldwide Leader, of being a homer as I think he consciously goes out of his way to avoid those accusations. But come on. Yes, Wells looked good against Michigan last year but does he really have the potential to be better, which is what he’s done by ranking him higher than the others, than Noel Devine of West Virginia, Murray, McKnight? Flatly, is he a better running back than those three guys? No. He just isn’t.

Here’s something I just feel the need to say for the record. I’m not a believer in Anthony Morelli, Penn State’s senior quarterback who everyone, including our buddy Herbie, is expecting to have a breakout year in ’07. Last year, the only year he has put up stats of any import, the kid threw 11 TDs and 8 INTs while completing less than 55 percent of his passes. Those aren’t good numbers. Heck, those aren’t even decent numbers. In games against the Big Ten’s three best teams last year (Michigan, Ohio State, Wisconsin), Morelli threw a grand total of ZERO touchdowns and four interceptions. All of last season, he never had a game where he threw for more than 300 yards. My guess is that the Penn State staff isn’t as sold on Anthony Morelli as sportswriters in the country appear to be. And looking at his stats, I can’t say that I blame him. If Penn State fails to knock off Ohio State, Wisconsin or Michigan, Morelli will be a big part of the reason why. Count on it.

Since I’m sure you’re dying to know. Herbie picked Florida to win the East, LSU to win the west and the Bayou Bengals to take the conference championship.

Here’s the link.

11 comments on “The Herbies

  1. Herbie is scared of SEC speed, just ask him

  2. I’m gonna take some flak for this, but I’ll say it anyway…

    It will be interesting to see what Devine can really do…

    While he piled up great numbers in HS and has a terrific set of highlight material…

    The bulk of his HS team’s schedule was made up of schools that had sub .500 win percentages over the last two years…

    And to be honest, the tackling in those reels is some of the worst defense I’ve ever seen…

    Pop Warner included…

    NFMHS was the only team in their district with a winning record last season, I believe…

    Devine has looked terrific in HS, but lets no annoint him a great RB just yet…

  3. based on your devine/competetion rant, he should be just fine playing in the Big East

  4. WTF is herban meyer up to? http://sports.yahoo.com/ncaaf/news?slug=ap-t25-florida-moody&prov=ap&type=lgns

  5. Just pickin’ up Pete’s sloppy seconds…

  6. you can put 11 five stars on the field at once

  7. ksdjhjksadhl ajkfh sdljkh948u094 23jhwqe0!*)& kopm~!

  8. But you can’t put ten running backs n the field at once…

  9. we should have called that the herpes

  10. I think doing a list of stuff like that is a terrible idea for Herbie… Granted everyone is still gonna love him…. but it basically makes 5-10 team’s fan bases happy while leaving another 80 or so that think they have the best stuff saying he’s wrong. Maybe it would be different if he changed it up sometimes.

    3 terrible sounding Big 10 bands at the top of the list. At least it’s better than giving it to half of the SEC bands that play with music.

  11. F him. I would not drop a deuce on Kirk

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 545 other followers